Yeah, the show dips into the supernatural now and then, but it’s never spelled out 100%. It’s more like these strange, almost mythical elements drift into the story. Season 1 has that rain of fish — straight out of the Bible or a tall tale. Season 2 has the infamous UFO sighting during the massacre, which is either an alien encounter or just a bizarre coincidence nobody can explain. Season 3 plays with more symbolic weirdness with V.M. Varga feeling almost like a demon in a business suit. The Coens themselves always liked mixing realism with the surreal — think of A Serious Man or the dream sequences in The Big Lebowski — so the series kind of carries that over. The 'supernatural' in Fargo isn’t ghosts or spells; it’s more like the universe winking at you, or shoving something impossible into the middle of an otherwise grounded crime story.
